Public Policy
  Analysis, opinion & ideas from Steve Harry

Directory

About/Contact

Schor is a master at raising money

June 22, 2021

 

I can't wait for July 23. That's when the pre-primary campaign finance reports are due and we'll be able to see how much Andy Schor has raised so far this year - how much he's raised on top of the $179,750 he had in his Schor for Lansing campaign account at the end of 2020. Since November 2017, after he defeated Judi Brown Clark in his first race for mayor - outspending her by over $200,000 - he has raised $92,621. During that time (11/28/2017-12/31/2020), he has spent $1,138.97. His biggest expense was $337.43 for credit card processing.

 

I've compiled the details from the 9 campaign finance reports he has submitted since the 2016 election. (I downloaded them from the Ingham County Clerk's website.)

Contributions sorted by contributor name

Contributions sorted by amount

I also attempted to determine which individuals/companies/groups/PACs were the biggest contributors. Here are the ones who contributed over $1000:

Plumbers & Pipefitters Local 333 PAC $10,000
Michigan Regional Council of Carpenters PAC 8,500
IBEW PAC 6,500
Midwest Strategy Group 5,700
Grewal Law 5,200
The Christman Company 4,580
McAlvey Merchant & Associates 3,350
Boji Group 2,600
Michigan Beer and Wine Wholesalers 2,500
Miller Canfield 2,500
City of Lansing employees 2,400
Honigman Law 2,250
Neogen Corporation 2,100
John Holman 2,000
Modest Ventures, LLC 1,500
Government Consultant Services Inc 1,500
Dewpoint 1,250
Fishbeck, Thompson, Carr & Huber, Inc 1,200

Here is the detail from which I compiled the above totals.

 

Some of the contributions came from fundraisers:

 

 

Date

# Attendees

Type

Location

Total Contributions

Cost

 
 

7/19/2018

70

Beer Tasting

209 N. Capitol, Suite 1

$9,550

$0

 
 

12/10/2019

35

Holiday Happy Hour

420 E. Michigan Ave (Nuthouse)

$2,000

$213.98

 
 

11/16/2020

0

 (cancelled)

518 E. Shiawassee

$9,850

$0

 

 

Here are the expenditures reported for 11/28/2017-12/31/2020;

 

Recipient Purpose Date

Amount

Bieda for Congress Fundraiser Ticket 3/24/2018 100.00
Celentino for Commissioner Fundraiser Ticket 3/18/2018 100.00
Committee to Elect Jim Haadsma Fundraiser Ticket 3/24/2018 100.00
Committee to Elect Todd Tennis Fundraiser Ticket 6/9/2018 100.00
Friends of Karen Weaver Fundraiser Ticket 3/24/2018 100.00
Horrocks Food for event 6/13/2019 87.56
Nuthouse Food & Beverage for Event 12/10/2019 213.98
Direct Connect Credit Card Processing 12/2/2020 337.43
    TOTAL: 1,138.97

 

Back in April 2018, in a story called Overkill: Candidate Schor outspent Brown Clarke by over $200,000, I said

 

  I just don't understand the need for all that money. The City Pulse predicted a Schor win soon after Virg Bernero announced he wasn't running. Schor could have won easily with the $90,000 left over from his state representative campaign account. Is it to scare away future challengers by showing how much money he can raise?  

 

"$90,000 left over from his state representative campaign account." Maybe that is the answer. At the time he decides to run for higher office - governor, U.S. representative, U.S. senator - he'll be able to transfer to that campaign the money he has left in his mayoral campaign account.

 

In addition to his Schor for Lansing campaign finance committee, he has a Section 527 account to raise money for contributions and expenses unrelated to his mayoral campaign. I wrote about it in November 2019. Those reports are posted to the IRS website. He has submitted 5 electronic reports covering all of 2019 and 2020, but none as yet for 2021. Unlike the campaign finance reports, the 527 reports don't provide beginning and ending balances, but do provide contribution and expenditure totals:

Period

Contributions

Expenditures

1/1/2019-12/31/2019

25,338

22,707

1/1/2020-3/31/2020

15,565

7,248

4/1/2020-6/30/2020

3,096

25,900

7/1/202-09/30/2020

716

6,250

10/1/2020-12/31/2020

1,559

2,551

TOTAL:

46,274

64,656

Apparently he had a large balance in the account before he started reporting electronically. Here is the detail on contributions:

527 contributions sorted by contributor

527 contributions sorted by amount

527 contributions sorted by date

Here are the employers/employees who contributed $1,000 or more:

 

Board of Water & Light employees 3,200
AF Group (Accident Fund) 3,000
Blue Cross Blue Shield 2,000
Ferguson Development 2,000
Michigan Regional Council of Carpenters 2,000
Public Policy Associates 1,072
UAW 1,050
Advance Midwest 1,000
Rachel and Ben Amber 1,000
Eng, Inc 1,000
Grewal Law 1,000
Lansing Medical Cannabis Guild 1,000
Martin Waymire 1,000
Miller Canfield 1,000

Some of the reported "expenditures" for the 2019-2020 period were actual expenses, but the bulk was donations to community groups and events. I present them separately below, but in some instances it was hard to tell which was an expense and which was a donation:

Actual expenses

Donations

I suspect that using 527 funds for donations is uncommon. Former mayor Virg Bernero didn't do it - in fact, he spent a lot on personal stuff unrelated to the holding of office, including 980 restaurant meals over his 12 years as mayor. You can see them in my 11-page compilation of expenditures sorted by purpose. The meals start on page 4. He also spent nearly $5,000 on flowers from Fortino's Flowers in Pontiac. Turns out that shop is owned by family.

 

How can Schor be faulted for making all those donations? For one thing, it is not his money. It is contributed by businesses who probably want something from his administration. His generosity is with other people's money.

 

In addition, those donations are likely to make recipients feel more favorably toward the mayor and more likely to vote for him. It is a clever campaign tactic.

 

Send comments, questions, and tips to stevenrharry@gmail.com or call or text me at 517-730-2638. If you'd like to be notified by email when I post a new story, let me know.

 

Previous stories